Champion Home

Bus riders frustrated with MARTA cutback plan

David Griswold put the prospect of MARTA bus route cutbacks in plain terms as he sat waiting for a bus in Decatur on March 15.

“It’s messed up,” he said. “It’s going to cause a lot of problems.”

Griswold, 32, of Decatur said he works in a restaurant off Candler Road, a job he’s had for just three months. He said he also uses MARTA’s bus system to visit with friends and travel generally around the city.

He said he heard about a recent plan to cut back bus service by reducing or eliminating certain routes – nearly half of those in DeKalb, MARTA officials said – but hasn’t looked to see if he’ll be affected. He said he often uses bus routes 116, 114 and 32. All of them have cuts proposed.

“I really ain’t making any money right now,” Griswold said. Even worse, “it’d be really hard to find a job on a bus line.”

The cutbacks represent a dramatic reshuffling of public transportation service throughout the Atlanta area. As the economy has worsened, revenue from a 1-cent sales tax has plummeted, and over the last decade, expenditures have outpaced revenues. Revenues last year were $332.9 million. Expenditures were $382.3 million.

That said, the MARTA system doesn’t usually turn a profit save for a stretch between fiscal years 1991 and 1997, MARTA data show. Traditionally, those deficits were relatively small, though fiscal year 2003’s deficit was $21.4 million.

Had MARTA not made serious cost cutting measures, this year’s projected deficit would have ballooned to $109.6 million, data show. Next year, MARTA is predicting a $120 million deficit, and in fiscal year 2012, the system is projecting a $127.6 million deficit. The budget reductions have already been approved by a heavily cash-strapped legislature, and MARTA officials are asking metro residents to contact legislators to restore service in the future.

“Nationwide trends in population and demographics, land use and development and energy consumption, along with significant public interest in environmental sustainability and increasing economic competition between states and metropolitan areas all provide a compelling case for greater investment in public transportation,” said a MARTA document titled “The Case for Investment.”

Griswold said he uses bus route 32, also named Eastland/Bouldercrest. Under MARTA’s proposed cuts, the route would no longer service Hill Street. He also uses route 114, also known as Columbia Drive. Service there will no longer be provided along Clifton Springs Road between Clifton Springs Health Center and Clifton Church Road.

Jessica Rodriguez, 25, of Decatur also heard about the proposed cuts. She, too, said she wasn’t sure whether her usual routes would be affected. She said she often uses route 125 or Avondale/Northlake. Service on that route will no longer be provided on Montreal Circle. She also uses the 114.

“Most people ain’t got cars these days,” she said as she waited for the bus. She said she worries about what she might need to do if one of her routes gets cut. “I would have to dial 411 and call Obama. I’d be stuck.”

Ebony Taylor, 25, of Decatur also uses the bus to get around. She said she doesn’t have a job, and the bus is her only means of searching for one. Reduced routes, for her, also means reduced job options, she said.

The cuts may even affect teenagers. Briana Foster, 17, of Stone Mountain was waiting for the bus March 15, clutching a silver purse. She said she uses the bus for two things: shopping and school. Foster said she is getting her GED from a facility in Atlanta, adding that she uses route 34, also known as Gresham Park. Service on that route will no longer be provided on Vicki Lane, Flagstone Drive, Flintwood Drive, Rollingwood Lane, Boulderview Drive, Horse Shoe Drive Sombrero Way and Corral Drive.

She wondered whether she’ll be able to continue to get to school easily.

“It might be hard,” she said.

 

 

 


Comments (15)

Said this on 10/1/10 At 10:04 am
I ride marta at least 5 days a week to and from work. This particular morning the bus was so full, there was not even standing room for one more person to get on. When I leave today to go home, the bus will be full when it leaves the station and by the time it makes it 1/4 of the way through it's route it will be full. Some days, it gets so full that it simply has to pass people that have been waiting for 15-20 minutes because there is no space on the bus.

Marta is a textbook example of everything wrong with public transit. They removed a couple of routes in my neighborhood due to "low ridership". If a sardine can is their idea of normal ridership, they were probably what the bus manufacturers consider safe and normal capacity.

I also question them using union drivers (I don't think unions are necessarily always bad). Unions have their place to keep workers from being treated poorly, they can also be bad when they have too much control. I regularly see drivers take too long of breaks at the stations (going by the schedule of when the bus is supposed to depart). If a bus is already over capacity and leaves the station late, that will only compound problems. I have also seen some great drivers and some shoddy ones. The shoddy ones like to talk with someone on the bus and not pay attention, this results in them forgetting someone has requested a stop or not seeing a person waiting @ a stop. They don't seem to care.

I also think Nici is spot on except the fact that most riders who ride it 7 days a week will get a monthly or weekly pass. The $4 a day is probably a little off the mark. The current 30 day pass is $68, that would work out to 408,000,000 if every one of the 500,000 used it which is not the case. It's probably between 728 and 408 million. This still does not mach their numbers and I would not be surprised if the upper echelons of management have some sort of embezzlement going on.

They need to bring in some management with experience in working transit systems and get rid of the management in place.
Kris
Said this on 3/25/10 At 03:56 am
Marta has 2 major problems: 1) MARTA has little government funding, and 2) The upper-level management gets payed way too much.
The first problem is because everyone gets upset when new taxes are even suggested, let alone imposed. Come on people, you don't get something for nothing!
The second problem is the same for every other company in th US. We all want to be rich, so we all do what we can to increase our pay rate.

I truly wish that MARTA wouldn't cut service, since my GF uses it to get to-and-from work. I also use it to get around, and the routes that we both use are looking at elimination.
C Mack
Said this on 3/24/10 At 09:15 pm
The reason marta has not worked is because the outer counties have not supported marta. The Governor and other locals never pushed to support marta.Look at the massive traffic congestion.It was all planned to keep the people on the southside from excess to north georgia.Not only that , they new that most of the companies were leaving downtown and moving north.Leaving the people south with no jobs. It was all by design.Believe it or not.
Tiffany
Said this on 3/24/10 At 10:09 am
I believe MARTA is working with what they have. I don't think that the State has done enough to aid MARTA when they could have. I don't want to compare MARTA with New York or Washington D.C.'s transit system because when you compare, you belittle. I just would like to see some support from the State for what is a means to aid people to get where they need to go.
Bill
Said this on 3/24/10 At 01:59 am
Nici: You calculations are not correct. You grossly over-estimate in two area: ridership and fees. For ridership, the 500,000 figure (it's actually about 430,000) is a measure of how many times per day either the train system or a bus is entered by a passenger. Many passengers have 3 legs (a bus to a train to a bus) on their one-way commute. If we figure that passengers use, on average, two MARTA legs for each direction of their commute, we see that there are actually only about 110,000 people riding each day. For fees, the regular riders pay $15/week for unlimited trips, not the $28 that you calculated. So, MARTA should take in something much closer to 110,000x$15x52=$85.8million per year, not $728million.
TC
Said this on 3/23/10 At 03:26 pm
The reason Marta is so broke is because Marta is a terrible form of transportation. Everyone in Atlanta who has to ride Marta even once makes it their life's goal to get a car, which is probably at least half of the reason traffic is so bad here.

Don't feel sorry for Marta. If they were better at what they did then more people would rely on them. I've come from places with real public transportation, like in New York and Philadelphia...both systems put Marta to shame. They are Atlanta's shame, and a sham. I've never seen worse public transportation in my life, and this is just another example of their poor decisions.
Lillian Santiago
Said this on 3/23/10 At 12:30 pm
MARTA may not be the best transit system, but probably would be better if it were funded correctly. No mass transit is expected to make money, and with the obstructionist politicians in Georgia it definitely won't. They would prefer to give budget money to fish and horses than to working people who use MARTA, or elderly or disabled people.
Samantha
Said this on 3/21/10 At 04:36 pm
What does President Obama have to do with this? NOTHING! Get over it!!! He IS PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA!!! IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT THEN MAYBE YOU SHOULD MOVE SOME WHERE ELSE!!!
Samantha
Said this on 3/21/10 At 04:35 pm
I agree with you 100%
Samantha
Said this on 3/21/10 At 04:33 pm
MARTA sucks! I used to have to depend on it for EVERYTHING for years and I thank GOD I don't anymore. They are ALWAYS going up on their prices, but their service seems to be getting worse!

I used to live in Midtown and depended on MARTA. Because of where I lived it was easy. I feel for the people that has to depend on MARTA for transportation. They can not begin to compare to New York...their prices are too high. They are ALWAYS claiming to be 'broke' and need more money..so what do they do? Cut routes...the next thing they will do is hike up their prices.

The trains on the East and West bound takes way too long! They need to increase bus routes in Lithonia and many other areas instead of decreasing them.

I now reside in DeKalb County and if they are cutting at least 1/2 of the routes out here then why are we STILL paying taxes on a service that we will hardly ever receive? I say that DeKalb County residents should NOT have to pay that tax anymore!

I also find that MARTA supervisors are lazy good for nothing but holes!!!! All they do is drive around all day and NEVER know anything about nothing! One time I asked a 'so called' supervisor where a certain bus was going from a certain station that I was at and she didn't know...nor did she take the time to find out an answer for me! How pitiful is that???
dave
Said this on 3/20/10 At 07:37 am
this is why atlanta is nowhere yet to be on a big city scale wit nyc and dc level. wit all the major corporations located here transporatation should be alot better than wat it is. i mean come on wit wats up wit all this county power??? cobb, gwinnett, and clayton dont want marta but they have they own bus system wtf!!!!!! why dont they just have marta run those counties as the main transportation like other cities do. this is why atlanta is overrated and slow as compared to other major cities and the reason why atlanta is not yet in the dumps is because of there cost of living. if not for that it really would be no point living here!!!!!
Banjoman
Said this on 3/20/10 At 12:18 am
Nici is on-point. Excellent analysis and insights.
Nici
Said this on 3/19/10 At 06:35 pm
@ Bernard - I believe its the second one. And Marta is not broke, they have money. This is just another way for them to save more money and rip people off. Especially the ones that heavily rely on Marta 7 days a week. Too many people (approx. 500,000 or more people) ride Marta everyday so lets do the math. 500,000 people pay $4 per day equals $2 million per day. Times that by 7 which is 7 days a week equals $14 million per week. Now times $14 million by 52 which is 52 weeks in a year you should get $728 million dollars per year. If my calculations are correct, then someone is lying and pocketing a lot of "our" money for themselves and their selfish needs, and loving it.
Richard Karas
Said this on 3/19/10 At 01:37 pm
Thats right, better call Obama.... He will fix it.



Sadly, MARTA is the only major city public transportation that recieves NO SUPPORT from its local governments. CALL AND WRITE YOUR LOCAL LAWMAKERS TO STOP THIS OUTTRAGE!
Bernard Wallace
Said this on 3/18/10 At 11:09 pm
Is this America or is this a concept posing as an idea blinded by greed...

New comments are currently disabled.


Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for News Alerts